Skip to content
SpinxCore

Tourism Management: Might a £5 ‘Entry’ Charge Help Balance The Islands' Needs with Tourist Demand?

Artisan jewelry, souvenir and whiskey stores line the central avenue of Kirkwall on Orkney. Kirkwall also features a recently opened Japanese restaurant, providing bento boxes and matcha cheesecake.

Historically inhabited by the Norse rulers who governed the islands, Kirkwall has hit it rich: it leads the UK’s charts for passenger liner visits, as American, European and Italian tourists flock to remarkable ancient sites such as the prehistoric village and its historic cathedral.

But many local residents are frustrated: accommodating about half a million visitors a year, twentyfold the local population of 22,000, has a significant cost. Its small streets are jammed, local transport overwhelmed, the neolithic stones at the Ring of Brodgar are now fenced off to fix the wear and tear by visitors. A number of visitors, unable to find toilets, have reportedly been accused of relieving themselves outdoors.

Finding it Difficult to Afford the Expenses of Visitor Facilities

Struggling to afford the expenses of constructing additional toilets, bus parking areas and paths to adequately cater for visitors, the local authority and its industry representatives want the power to establish a new fee for every tourist who arrives on the islands, by either sea or flight.

Orkney islands council has teamed up with Shetland and Western Isles council to urge the Scottish government to legislate for a point of entry levy included in tickets charged by ship companies, boat services and the islands airline the regional airline.

Martin Fleet, chief executive of the family-owned jewelry business a renowned brand, and head of the business group the tourism board, calculates that a flat rate five pound fee for each tourist could generate around two million pounds a year, once operational expenses are subtracted.

“The islands, neighboring isles, the Outer Hebrides, which have limited residents, have remarkable sites which people want to come and see, but we’ve got to make sure that we preserve those heritage sites for posterity who reside locally and also those that plan to travel here,” he said.
“We don’t want people to stop visiting here. We simply require to be highly conscious about how it’s managed.”

Government Considering Tourist Levy Proposals

The national administration has confirmed it is evaluating a point of entry surcharge as part of a wider review on introducing a charge particularly for cruise ships, which local governments with busy harbors could utilize for improved visitor facilities and community amenities.

Local officials argue vociferously that visitor charges are essential to support a £647m shortfall in public finances and to help them cope with the vast numbers of tourists Scotland attracts each year. Outcomes of the consultation are due out in the near future.

The nation currently possesses the UK’s first law to permit local authorities to implement a “overnight levy” – a visitor levy on hotels, bed and breakfasts and camping grounds. Edinburgh’s has come into force, with tourists currently charged a 5% additional fee on every booking booked from July 24th, 2026 forward, limited at five nights.

Other major cities are following suit, but additional local authorities across the northern regions have declined that option, frequently after a opposition from enterprises, arguing a charge on accommodations is too burdensome and is also unappealing for customers.

Alternative Solutions for Island Communities

The Shetland Islands has turned down a visitor levy; Orkney and the Western Isles have “paused” it, hoping a better solution such as a point of entry levy arrives.

Cruise Scotland, an industry body, has protested that a cruise ship levy will deter many of the 1.2 million travelers who visit each year, “causing serious consequences for the nation's cruise sector, its fragile coastal economies, and the nation's standing as a globally competitive tourism destination”.

Local authorities contends a point of entry charge considers all tourists fairly. This includes the 214,000 cruise ship travelers who landed there in 2024 and the 173,000 who arrived by boat and flight, including RV users, outdoor enthusiasts and lodging patrons, and those on personal boats.

The council and Historic Environment Scotland, the agency which safeguards Orkney’s ancient UNESCO site, are immersed in an exhaustive initiative to build a recently planned tourist center, bus parking, access paths and toilets to accommodate crowds at the ancient stone circle and Skara Brae.

Partially financed by the regional development fund set up by the UK and Scottish governments, that could take up to eight years to achieve: constructing on a scheduled historic monument is a painstaking process.

Local and Industry Perspectives

Christie Hartley, the authority's responsible travel team manager, stated the Scottish government needed to outline its thinking soon, to prevent the cruise sector “getting riled up”, but she noted a levy would advantage everyone involved.

“Generally speaking, there is little relationship typically between cruise lines and the local residents that they promote – they sell a pair of elements: the journey of their ships and the destinations,” she said.

Although they have a highly effective relationship with bus operators and port officials, “how about the local populations that we have a responsibility to safeguard and support? This is a significant opportunity for us to actually build those relationships to mutual benefit.

“If we invest in facilities, they can improve the experience for their guests, they can increase prices, they can have the assurance of being certain what they’re going to get. It's well known we have issues with the lack of toilets and things in our fragile locale that are challenging to manage with the number of people.”

A local councillor, a councillor and head of Orkney’s planning and facilities committee, stated tourists are more and more eco-conscious and socially aware. “There is an opportunity there: to have a effective system in operation, to have a positive relationship and for this levy to truly prove highly beneficial,” he said.

About the author

Caroline Murphy

A tech enthusiast and business strategist with over a decade of experience in digital transformation and innovation.

SpinxCore

Type to search articles.